Balancing the 2nd Amendment

Bajaba Q
May 23, 2023
edited January 18, 2026

The 2nd Amendment of the US Constitution

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Commentary

While gun ownership is a right and personal safety is not explicitly protected, a balance protecting both should be possible. I simply do not think a society where my children practice active-shooter-drills is one where “no-action” is the correct action. Maybe the following would help (I think it is mostly carrot and little stick).

Gun shop owners, or private salesmen, would receive a 100% tax credit on the cost of a gun, if prior to the sale of a gun, would ensure the gun buyer shows proof of:

The tax-credit on the cost of the gun would hopefully entice many gun shop owners to participate in this program by increasing their profits by 100% on each sale.

The fitness-for-duty and training could be based on US Army or National Guard standards. Both of these classes could be held on a regular schedule at a local National Guard Armory and Military Bases.

The fitness-for-duty for duty would be an evaluation of a person’s physical and mental health to ensure they would be a competent, safe, and responsible gun-owner.

The training would consist of classroom and field components to ensure the participant knows their weapon and demonstrates competence when using it. Different training would be offered for pistol, rifle, etc.

To ensure continued “fitness for duty”, perhaps the cost of 12 boxes of ammunition could also be eligible for a 100% tax credit, upon annual mental/physical evaluation and demonstration of proficiency.

Additionally, the cost of the required fitness-for-duty evaluation and training classes could either be offered for free or could be paid for by the participants or a tax-credit could be offered to participants.

Conclusion

As always, I would be interested in hearing other perspectives or suggested modifications to this proposal.